The equation
is written on the board, with linear factors on each side. What is the least possible value of for which it is possible to erase exactly of these linear factors so that at least one factor remains on each side and the resulting equation has no real solutions?
.
.
.
.
Hint 1: If appears on both sides, then is a solution. So for each , at least one copy must be erased. This gives .
Hint 2: Can we achieve ? Partition into and , keeping for on the left and for on the right.
Hint 3: Choose the partition so the products and never agree. If they have different degrees, they can only agree at finitely many points — but check real roots carefully.
Step 1 (Setup): After erasing factors, we have where is a product of some of the factors and is a product of the remaining factors from the right side. We need for all real .
Step 2 (Key observation): If any factor remains on both sides, then is a solution (both sides are 0). So we must erase enough factors so that for each , the factor is missing from at least one side.
Step 3 (Lower bound ): For each , at least one copy of must be erased (otherwise solves the equation). There are 2016 values of , so at least 2016 factors must be erased.
Step 4 ( achievable): Erase all factors from the left side, leaving the right side intact? No — at least one factor must remain on each side. Instead: erase all 2016 factors from the left side except one, and erase one from the right side... we need exactly total erasures.
The strategy: for each , erase from exactly one side. This uses 2016 erasures. After erasing, the left side is a product of factors for and the right side is a product of for . We need for all real .
Since and partition with and , and degrees differ when , the polynomials have different degrees (unless ). Choose : the two sides have different degrees, so they can agree at only finitely many points... but we need NO real solutions.
For a more careful argument: choose (odd) and (even). Both sides have degree 1008. Check that for all by analyzing signs in each interval. Actually, for between consecutive integers, the signs interleave. A careful choice of and ensures strict inequality everywhere.
Ready to track your progress and master these topics?
Create a free account